you're reading...

The Hunger Games & Artful Potential

A recent article by Joal Ryan at eonline.com (http://www.eonline.com/news/five_reasons_hunger_games_will_not_be/301941) entitled “Five Reasons The Hunger Games Will Not Be Bigger Than Harry Potter” seems to have crossed the realm into useless speculative banter by an online entertainment news giant trying to make an editorial splash where there is not one to be made at all. The article lists several points as to why the author believes that when The Hunger Games may become bigger than the Twilight series, it will assuredly not become bigger than the juggernaut Harry Potter series.

Point #1 ~ Family-Friendly Fantasy vs. Dystopian Mayhem

The author of this article claims that PG family-friendly mayhem will win out vs. what she calls the dystopian mayhem of the Hunger Games. I believe the Twilight series proved that notion wrong. From Harry Potter to Twilight to The Hunger Games, the teen focused movie market has obviously been progressing upon a certain line and indeed growing up with those same teen that watched Harry Potter at a very young age. Please don’t forget that it is these same kids that are now between 14 and 19 years old now. They have been growing up, and so has the subject matter in which attracts them. Furthermore, a larger part of the adult market than previously thought had bought into what everyone thought was a solely teen focused market movie in Twilight. As The Hunger Games shows its stuff, I believe it will garner as much or more of the general market than expected. After all, it is the new artful adult/teen cross-over movie.

Point #2 ~  Source Material

Here the author claims that The Hunger Games also will not unseat Harry Potter because it has much less book sales. First of all, The Hunger Games is a trilogy. The Harry Potter series includes seven books. Comparing singular volumes of the two book series seems guess work at best.

Point #3 & #4 ~  High Bar & Highest Bar

Comparing opening weekend numbers between the two is completely useless due to different ticket prices and different release dates. We also have to mention that societal trends of today are different than when the Potter series first hit the screen. When it is true that may not be a huge difference, it is still a factor. Perhaps, a better current comparison would be with the Twilight series. One has to wonder as to why Mrs. Ryan even made a point #4 here. Was he trying to get to a certain word count? Nah, that never happens in journalism submissions. (wink, wink)

Point #5 ~ International Flava

To think that The Hunger Games will be any less successful than Harry Potter because they didn’t use a corral of English actors is preposterous. Maybe Joal Ryan favors english pedigree actors? Hmmm.

Joal’s Bottom Line: is my point exactly. There has been no proof nor reason for the original article in the first place.

My Bottom Line:

At first glance, The Hunger Games seems to be an intelligent and artful progression from the days of Harry Potter and Twilight. Of course, the ticket draw will tell the tale as to who will win that war, but it does not tell the tale of which series will win best pictures or series between the two. After a cadre of Harry Potter films, I will be more than happy to be introduced to a brand new world…no matter how dystopian it is.

~ Erik Sudberg


About thetumultuoustimes

I am just a citizen of the world expressing opinions about a world that is in dire need of change.


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

The Tumultuous Times

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 29 other followers


Blog Stats

  • 9,559 hits
%d bloggers like this: